It was a food and beverage pairing showdown this past Wednesday as Todd Rushing of
Concentrics Restaurants and Crawford Moran of
5 Seasons Brewing competed in a five-course challenge. Chef Drew Van Leuvan of ONE midtown kitchen and Chef David Larkworthy of 5 Seasons cooked up the dinner showcasing local fall produce. Rushing selected a wine pairing for each course while Moran chose a beer pairing and guests were invited to decide for themselves which was most pleasing.
MenuFirst Course: Georgia Shrimp Ceviche, turnips, tarragon, lemon

Wine: Aligoté.
Beer: Gueuze Fond Tradition, non-filtered lambic by St. Louis.
* To my palate, the wine won by a million miles. The beer sniffed of athletic socks and tasted like sour lemons. The guy sitting next to me, who seemed to be very familiar with lambics, admitted that this wasn't the tastiest example of it that he'd ever had. Regardless, I won't be running out to buy one. Had I been blindfolded, I'd have guessed the wine was a sauvignon blanc; it had strong citrus and grassy notes with a solid acid backbone.
Second Course: Potato Gnocchi, bay scallops, arugula, preserved tomato broth

Wine: Vin d' Alsace 2007 Helfrich Gewurztraminer
Beer: Numbers Ale (#'s Ale)
* Todd Rushing makes Numbers Ale in a partnership with Atlanta Brewing Company and so he pointed out that he couldn't lose this round. I actually preferred the beer over the wine with this dish. The sweet notes of the wine didn't provide much contrast to the sweet dish while the beer offered soft honey notes in tune with it while also providing a refreshing malty contrast.
Third Course: Crisp Pork Rillette, mushrooms, fontina veloute...
...The chefs had a bit of fun plating this third course, perhaps after enjoying several sips of the wine and beer pairing options? The risqué appearance was surprising and even a bit off-putting, but Van Leuvan admitted to me that he'd hoped someone would get it. How could anyone overlook such an obvious phallic symbol? (Seriously, this is exactly how it was plated and presented.)

Wine: Bouchard Aine & Fils 2007 Pinot Noir
Beer: Aventinus Wheat Doppelbock
* Both pairings were excellent. The dark Bavarian beer, made one day out of the year, has chocolate and banana notes. The wine balanced soft earth with juicy red fruit.
Fourth Course: Braised Veal Cheeks, carrots, potato, pancetta, bernaise

Wine: St. Francis Winery RED 2005 Sonoma County
Beer: Petrus Brown Ale
* Again, both great pairings. The wine had figgy flavors with a punch of acidity. The beer had sour and woody notes.
Fifth Course: Parsnip Spice Cake, cream cheese frosting, bosc pear sorbet

Wine: Foris Muscat Frissante
Beer: Corsendonk Christmas Ale
* Both were good pairings, but I preferred the wine with its wonderful orange and honeysuckle aromas.
Bottom line: There were no losers in this battle.
No need to wait until the next Beer Versus Wine Dinner to enjoy a great meal at
ONE midtown kitchen. The restaurant serves dinner daily. In addition to the menu that features local, organic produce in a range of eclectic dishes there's a nightly roast:
Monday = Bramlett Trout
Tuesday = Leg of Lamb
Wednesday = Niman Ranch Pork Rack
Thursday = Roasted Duck for 2
Friday = Lemon Sole on the bone
Saturday = Crisp Breast of Veal
Sunday = Milk-fed free bird chicken
Great food is also on tap at
5 Seasons Brewing, which currently has three locations. Don't miss the $1 boule of bread made using spent grains!